A dark bronze statue of a racehorse on a stone plinth under a clear blue sky, with racecourse buildings, a food kiosk and a few distant visitors behind it.

Makybe Diva’s Three Melbourne Cups Stolen From Flemington, and a Man Arrested While the Trophies Stay Missing

Two men allegedly smashed into a display cabinet at Flemington Racecourse at about 6.30am on Monday 16 November and took […]

Two men allegedly smashed into a display cabinet at Flemington Racecourse at about 6.30am on Monday 16 November and took the three Melbourne Cups won by Makybe Diva, Victoria Police said, according to The Age. A man was arrested that night, and as at 17 November the trophies have not been recovered.

Police had earlier described “an unknown number of offenders”, The Age reported on 16 November.

“Police are investigating a burglary and theft in Flemington on 16 November,” a Victoria Police statement said, as reported by 7NEWS.

Do you think Makybe Diva's three Melbourne Cups will be recovered intact?

Choose an answer, then select Vote.

The Arrest

On the night of Monday 16 November, police executed a search warrant at a home in Melbourne’s south-east, 7NEWS reported. A 36-year-old man was arrested, interviewed and released pending summons, according to 7NEWS and The Age.

Vehicles were seized but had not yet been searched, a police spokesman told 3AW, The Age reported.

Police put out a statement on the afternoon of Monday 16 November, as quoted by The Age.

“The circumstances are yet to be established and an investigation into the incident is ongoing,” it said.

Queen of the Cups

The cups were on display in the Hill Stand at Flemington, between the Terrace and the Atrium, in an exhibition titled Makybe Diva: Queen of the Cups, according to The Age. The horse’s ashes are also on display there.

Makybe Diva won the Melbourne Cup in 2003, 2004 and 2005, 7NEWS reported. She is the only horse to win it three times and the only mare to win it more than once. She won $14.5 million in prize money, entered the Australian Racing Hall of Fame in 2006, and died in February 2026, aged 26, after colic. Her name comes from the first two letters of five of owner Tony Santic’s employees: Maureen, Kylie, Belinda, Diane and Vanessa.

Each trophy is estimated to be worth about $1 million, according to The Age and 7NEWS. A Melbourne Cup is made from 18-carat gold, weighs nearly two kilograms and takes more than 10 days to make, The Age reported.

The Owner and the VRC

Santic told The Age he learnt of the theft at 10am on Monday 16 November.

“The VRC called me and said they’d had a break-in and the three Melbourne Cups had been stolen,” he said.

“They told me the alarm went off and five minutes later security arrived, and they [the trophies] were gone.”

The VRC told him the thieves were believed to have worn high-vis clothing, Santic told The Age. The Age reported that police and the VRC had not confirmed reports of a disguise.

It is understood the VRC has shared CCTV footage with police, and that the display area had 24/7 surveillance and alarms, according to The Age.

“We are devastated by the incident and are in direct contact with Tony Santic [Makybe Diva’s owner],” the VRC said in a statement on Monday 16 November, The Age reported.

Santic also spoke about what the cups mean to him.

“They mean everything to me,” he told The Age. “They belong to the people as well. She [Makybe Diva] gave me and the people a lot, and I want to share that.”

“It’d be nice to get the Cups back. They’re irreplaceable,” he told Seven, 7NEWS reported.

The Fear of a Melt-Down

The worry is that the cups could be melted down for their gold. Jeweller Adrian Dickens, founder of Circa Ad Jewels, estimates each cup contains about 1.69 kilograms of 18-carat gold worth about $233,000, or $699,000 for all three, The Age reported. The $3 million figure is their value intact.

Melting them down would make the gold “totally untraceable”, Dickens told The Age.

Allan Trench, professor of mineral and energy economics at the University of Western Australia’s business school, said a trophy could be melted down in an hour, The Sydney Morning Herald reported.

“My first thought is good luck to police on this one,” he said.

Under anti-money laundering law, traders buying or selling precious metal products worth $10,000 or more must report the transaction, according to the regulator AUSTRAC, the Herald reported.

Where the Investigation Stands

It is not the first Melbourne Cup to go missing. In 1963 that year’s Melbourne Cup was stolen from a display window near Elizabeth and Collins streets in the CBD, and Phar Lap’s 1930 Melbourne Cup has long been missing, according to The Age.

As at 17 November, one man has been arrested and released pending summons, and the three cups have not been recovered. Investigations remain ongoing, and anyone with information is urged to contact Crime Stoppers, 7NEWS reported.

More Melbourne coverage is in our Melbourne archive, including Derby Day at the Flemington spring carnival.

Sources: The Age, “‘Totally untraceable’: Man arrested but $3m Makybe Diva Melbourne Cup trophies still missing”, 17 November 2026 (https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/man-arrested-cars-seized-but-no-makybe-diva-melbourne-cup-trophies-found-in-3m-heist-investigation-20261117-p61ep9.html); The Age, “‘They mean everything to me’: Thieves steal three Melbourne Cups won by Makybe Diva”, 16 November 2026 (https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/thieves-steal-three-melbourne-cups-won-by-makybe-diva-owner-says-20261116-p61el2.html); 7NEWS, “Man arrested in search for allegedly stolen Melbourne Cup trophies”, 17 November 2026 (https://7news.com.au/sport/man-arrested-in-search-for-allegedly-stolen-melbourne-cup-trophies--c-23170606); The Sydney Morning Herald, “‘Good luck to police on this one’: What thieves could do with three stolen Melbourne Cups”, 17 November 2026 (https://www.smh.com.au/business/consumer-affairs/good-luck-to-police-on-this-one-what-thieves-could-do-with-three-stolen-melbourne-cups-20261117-p61esf.html)

Photo: osedgman, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

The bronze statue of Makybe Diva at Flemington Racecourse, photographed in March 2010. It is not the Hill Stand exhibition from which the three cups were taken.

Scroll to Top